Emerald Publishing is piloting a crowd review process with Filestage to enhance the peer review process and improve the quality and speed of publishing.
Filestage provides a web application that enables easy sharing, commenting and approving of documents in the browser. Reviewers can mark required changes to files directly online, replacing long feedback rounds by e-mail and making the review workflow more efficient. The crowd review process was invented by Prof. Benjamin List form the Max Planck Institute for Coal Research (Mülheim a. d. Ruhr, Germany). The application was first introduced in publishing for Thieme’s journals SYNLETT in 2017 and SynOpen since 2018.
The crowd review process is an interactive, collaborative way to improve the quality and speed of publishing, with reviews being received on average within seven days, in comparison to most standard peer review processes which can take up to 60 days.
As part of the pilot, a select crowd of 30-50 reviewers will receive a link to the manuscript and have the ability to comment on it directly and anonymously via Filestage, a secure web interface. The interface also enables reviewers to interact with each other through the commenting functionality to improve collaboration between reviewers, the quality and usefulness of the feedback and remove the risk of bias by crowd intelligence.
The trial has been introduced to three of Emerald’s journals: Emerging Markets Case Studies; International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education; and Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research.
Brought to you by Scope e-Knowledge Center, a trusted global partner for digital content transformation solutions - Abstracting & Indexing (A&I), Knowledge Modeling (Taxonomies, Thesauri and Ontologies), and Metadata Enrichment & Entity Extraction.Click here to read the original press release.